Colorado · daily driver · ~$5–6k

Zoey's Car Finalists

The best of everything we've turned up — scored for the actual job: a dependable daily she can live with in Denver, run down I‑25 to see family in the Springs, and point up I‑70 to Copper all winter.

She wants: something cool · 4WD/AWD · can drive stick Must do: snow + mountains, reliably Priced: as listed 9/23

My read

After all the back‑and‑forth it's really heart vs. head. The Wagoneer is the cool, clean‑title, freshly‑sorted one she actually wants — and it holds its value. The Forester is the safe, sensible daily that eats I‑70 without drama. The Xterra Off‑Road is the cool‑and‑capable wildcard — if its transmission passes the coolant/SMOD check. The two Subarus are the low‑risk picks; the Jeep and the two trucks are the cool ones that hold value but drink more gas.

Ratings (1–5, my read): Cool · Dependable · Safety · Snow & mountains · Holds value · MPG = 4/5
Heart pick · front‑runner

1989 Jeep WagoneerLimited (XJ) · Colorado Springs

$5,000seller flexible from $6,000
Miles
142,000
Drivetrain
4WD
Engine
4.0L inline‑6
Trans
Automatic
Title
Clean
MPG
~15
Cool
Dependable
Safety
Snow/Mtn
Holds value
MPG
  • The Jeep she wants — clean title, rust‑free NM body
  • Fresh cooling, brakes, winter tires, whole fuel system
  • Bulletproof 4.0 six; you can fix anything on it
  • Actually appreciating — won't lose money
  • No airbags / ABS — old‑school safety
  • Parasitic battery draw + minor oil seep to sort
  • Thirsty (~15 mpg), loud on the highway

Best for Character, do‑it‑yourself peace of mind, and holding value.

View listing →
Sensible · safest daily

2013 Subaru Forester2.5X Premium · Thornton

$4,800her negotiated number
Miles
123,472
Drivetrain
AWD
Engine
2.5L boxer
Trans
Auto (4‑spd)
Title
Clean · 1 owner
MPG
~23
Cool
Dependable
Safety
Snow/Mtn
Holds value
MPG
  • Lowest miles here + one owner, paid off
  • Real modern safety (4/5 NHTSA), full‑time AWD
  • 8.7" clearance — great for snow & the Copper lot
  • No CVT — the robust 4‑speed auto
  • Confirm the timing belt was done (due ~105k)
  • Check for EJ25 head‑gasket seep
  • Sensible, not "cool"

Best for The safest, easiest, most economical daily on the list.

View listing →
Cool wildcard · most capable

2007 Nissan XterraOff‑Road · Denver

$5,500plus a set of tires
Miles
167,504
Drivetrain
4WD + locker
Engine
4.0L V6
Trans
Automatic
Title
Clean
MPG
~16
Cool
Dependable
Safety
Snow/Mtn
Holds value
MPG
  • Rugged‑cool Off‑Road trim — rear locker, real capability
  • Lowest miles of the cool trucks; holds value well
  • Strong 4.0 V6, timing chain (no belt)
  • SMOD check: '05–'10 autos can leak coolant into the trans — verify fluid isn't milky + radiator done
  • Needs tires; ~16 mpg

Best for Cool + genuinely trail‑capable — if the transmission checks out.

View listing →
The icon · runs forever

2002 Toyota 4RunnerSR5 · 3.4 V6 · Englewood

$5,800clean, well‑documented
Miles
295,600
Drivetrain
4WD
Engine
3.4L V6
Trans
Automatic
Title
Clean
MPG
~16
Cool
Dependable
Safety
Snow/Mtn
Holds value
MPG
  • Iconic; one‑family owned, rust‑free frame
  • Timing belt done '21; 3.4 V6 goes 350k+
  • Honest seller; appreciating platform
  • 295k miles — a lot to start a daily on
  • Older safety; hatch dent + faded roof; ~16 mpg

Best for Cool + will‑run‑forever, if the high miles don't scare you.

View listing →
Value · cheapest safe AWD

2011 Subaru Impreza2.5i Premium wagon · Aurora

$4,400lowest price here
Miles
136,849
Drivetrain
AWD
Engine
2.5L boxer
Trans
Auto (4‑spd)
Title
Clean
MPG
~22
Cool
Dependable
Safety
Snow/Mtn
Holds value
MPG
  • Cheapest way into a clean‑title AWD Subaru
  • Timing belt already done — one less worry
  • Modern safety; robust 4‑speed auto (no CVT)
  • Check for EJ25 head‑gasket seep
  • Low clearance (~5.7"); some dents/scratches
  • Sensible, not "cool"

Best for Maximum sense per dollar — safe AWD for the least money.

View listing →